Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Sun does move around the earth though. Doesn't it?



The entire sun moves around a point that is outside the sun. this point is on a more or less (Saturn) straight line to Jupiter.


It depends on the frame of reference, so you can correctly say that the sun goes around the earth.

You're instead thinking of heliocentrism vs geocentrism, which is about the planets as a whole revolving around the sun.

This is a common misguided gotcha question that is hilariously so confidently gotten wrong, just like what is heavier, a kilogram of lead or a kilogram of feathers? The former is heavier and I can prove it with one word.


no, I'm not thinking of that, I'm thinking of the fact that it is quite commonly pointed out that the earth-moon 2-body system rotates around a point 1000 miles below the surface of the earth (the center of the earth being 4000 miles below the surface); and I'm pointing out that if you are going to point that out about the earth-moon, it's even more interesting to point out the more dramatic situation regarding the sun-jupiter 2-body system where the point is outside of the sun.


This is such a good point, and the commonality and importance of it are underestimated (or not estimated at all) and underappreciated.


It doesn't (always). It depends on where the other planets are, and can range from near the center of the sun to outside its surface.


More like a long wobbly curly straw that goes around Sagitarius A*




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: