Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

...a clock which can be made from a ring oscillator, consisting of an odd number of NAND gates wired as NOT gates.



Oh wow, I didn't actually know that. Thanks for the interesting trivia


How do we know that that will converge to a single constant period of oscillation? Could you have a few different-sized square waves continue to cycle through the circuit?

(I've never built or simulated that, I'm just trying to imagine what could happen!)


>Could you have a few different-sized square waves continue to cycle through the circuit?

No.


Could you help improve my intuition about that, or give me a reference where I could learn more?


Okay, so I was wrong. You can get multiple harmonics if you use a long enough chain of inverters. I will simplify the paper mentioned in a sibling comment. In a long chain at any given point of time certain (variable number of) pairs of inverters drop in and out of the circuit changing the total propagation delay, giving rise to multiple harmonics. You'll have to read the paper for details.


First look up Barkhausen criteria, then read the following. For ring oscillators gain will be greater than unity for only those waves whose period matches the gate delay. Only one such wave exists since the gate delay is a fixed number.


It is possible for a ring oscillator to generate harmonics: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/iel5/16/31849/01482193.pdf


Interesting, would have loved to read the paper. Unfortunately I don't have an IEEE subscription right now.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: