Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Valid point, you're right that was more of a "let's have fun" than an actual reveal. However that doesn't change the fact that it's now an actual reveal.

On the earnings call he said the robot should be in production by the end of this year, and being sold by the end of next year. And implied it will:

- Be more valuable than everything else combined

- A sentient humanoid robot that is able to navigate reality and do tasks at request

- There is no meaningful limit to the size of the economy (whatever this means)

And finished up by saying "So that's what's going to happen"

I don't think I have Elon derangement syndrome, but I just can't take him seriously with how wildly inaccurate so many of his claims are.




What the actual quotes are, starting at 12:30 timestamp during investor questions segment:

"We are able to do simple factory tasks in the lab"

"We think we'll have Optimus in limited production in the factory doing useful tasks by the end of this year"

"We may be able to sell it externally by end of next year. These are just guesses"

For the first quote, they literally have a PR video on youtube showing this. Go see it for yourself.

For the second, this is a no-brainer. They already have robots in their factories doing useful tasks. It's not really a stretch that a humanoid form-factor robot could be doing the same.

For the third, he clearly said "may" and made it super clear this was a guess. He's also not saying it will be doing your dishes by end of next year, he said selling it externally. Which may be for external lab purposes or for other manufacturers.

"There is no meaningful limit to the size of the economy (whatever this means)"

I think it's pretty clear what it means - autonomous robots that can intelligently do human tasks are going to massively change how the economy works. And it's very, very likely that we will (at some point) get to here. He's not promising when that's going to be.

You're continuing to prove my point - people take the things he says and wildly misconstrue them and then act like he's literally Hitler. Don't get me wrong, Elon is an asshole and a transphobe and has some weird stick up his ass about immigration. But it's a pet peeve of mine for people to make up shit to be critical about while ignoring the real problems (like transphobia). It's also attacking the amazing talent and teams at Tesla/SpaceX for people to keep acting like it's a total shit show when it's really just Elon not shutting up sometimes


Thanks for spelling out your points, and I agree on some while disagreeing on others.

However, I in no way, nor ever would, say or act like he is literally Hitler. I’m not sure where you got such an extreme comparison from my comments about calling him out for unrealistic & hyperbolic statements.

I think at this point we can agree to disagree and see what the future holds for both Tesla and Elon


I didn't mean to accuse you of that, it was definitely some small hyperbole about mainstream opinions. I personally know people in life that would call Elon a Nazi without any irony or humor.

I hope the best for everyone, including Elon and the people around him


"Transphobia" in practice often just means rejecting the bizarre idea that men who say they are women somehow actually are women. Which is a good thing if you care about the rights of actual female women.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: