Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> "On September 5, the IDF released the results of its own investigation, finding that there was a "high possibility" that Abu Akleh was "accidentally hit" by army fire, but that it would not begin a criminal investigation"

I'm not sure what your point is here. Accidentally shooting someone is not a warcrime (there are details here in that it still could be if there is a certain level of negligence), and generally a criminal investigation would only be started if there was sufficient evidence in the preliminary investigation to suggest it was intentional.

Could israel be lying about it? Sure. Militaries doing cover ups would hardly be a new story. But this isn't the (metaphorical) smoking gun you think it is.

> In 1996...

1996 was quite a long time ago at this point.

> I also refuse the logic that Israel should investigate war crimes by its army

That's generally what is expected of any army under international law. If they don't then the higher ups become responsible.

In the event of a failure to prosecute, then it goes to the ICC to investigate and charge (israel isn't a member, but palestine is, so anything involving palestine nationals or territory counts, which is basically this whole war. If ICC didn't have juridsiction over something, then the procedure is the UN is supposed to create a special tribunal).

So its not like its solely up to israel to investigate/punish. That is just the first step and what is required for israel to comply with international law. If they fail to uphold their obligations there are other bodies to enforce albeit in practise powerful countries are often ignored by them.




So after I showed you examples from similar things happened in the past, your narrative now goes from

> We don't know yet whether or not Israel will charge the people involved in the aid worker bombing

To

> Could israel be lying about it? Sure. Militaries doing cover ups would hardly be a new story

> So its not like its solely up to israel to investigate/punish

Thanks for showing that this discussion is not useful.

PS:

> 1996 was quite a long time ago at this point.

So what? Holocaust was more than 80 years at this point? Does this make us forget this horrible history?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: