Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Do you feel like this focus on minutia versus substance has led you to miss otherwise insightful content?



Not OP, but I do the same, and no, not in the least. The amount of information available, even filtering for the best of the best by whatever heuristic I can choose, is vastly larger than my ability to process as a single person.

If anything, I've found that the faster I reject due to dark patterns, the better off and more informed I am. If something is truly worth learning about, it will bubble up again elsewhere soon enough.


I feel, personally, that 'signs of quality' are one of the best metrics an individual can have for making a decision to spend time on something.

Making a judgement on what to spend time on is literally the thing that allows for it to happen. Otherwise my time would be spent on shit.


Do you feel that a focus on dismissing and defending dark patterns is appropriate or constructive? What world are you helping construct, and what values are you supporting? Are you aiming for a world where open hardware becomes dominant and beneficial?

I feel the point was a valid red flag. This org may be more interested in marketing itself than it is in supporting open source.

Looking at their repos, we find that the designs for their robots are not public. This company is using the open core / artificial scarcity model for their hardware, while presenting themselves as a fully open source organization.

This is an organization exploiting open source for its marketing, without supporting open hardware.

This is important: Contributors looking for a real open hardware project to work on should consider looking elsewhere. If they contribute to this project, they would be contributing to a partially proprietary ecosystem. This tends to compromise the promise of Open hardware, which includes low cost replication and iteration on hardware designs.

Tldr: when an open source organization practices dark patterns, people need to hear about it. It's not a minute fact- it's a major compromise of Open source values and outcomes.


No. There's so much content fighting for my (limited) attention that there is no loss to ignore user-hostile sites.


I instinctively closed the popup, so I have no idea what I just agreed to...




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: