Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I think Apple just wanted their own Game of Thrones flagship, and on paper, Foundation seems like it should be that (epic scale, big ideas). But honestly, it needs a more subdued treatment: mostly talking heads in rooms, and an anthology that jumps forward decades with each episode, rotating characters as necessary.

Blockbuster narratives need heroes, which works directly at cross-purposes to the long-term systemic thinking that defines the books. There was probably never a scenario where the high price of buying the rights could match up with the size of audience for a more faithful adaptation. (And rightly or wrongly, non-book-readers seem broadly positive on the series.)




Julian May's Galactic Milieu might be that kind of thing. Start at Jack's book, maybe add Rogation's book as flashbacks. Th Rebellion and fury's antics give a good framework to let a bunch of writers add more material in between.


> I think Apple just wanted their own Game of Thrones flagship

Dune makes the most sense for TV and not the movies. A lot of the political subtlety is lost in the movies


Except that the other books are just wierd




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: