Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

And because I personally have never seen the problem, it couldn’t possibly exist!



If the problem is pervasive as made out to be, it stands to reason that a person would have at least one anecdotal experience in favor of the claim.


Given the massive variation in self checkouts, it's also possible you just live in a region which is on the High Quality end of the bell curve.


Which is more likely?

1. The people who say they have had a problem actually have had a problem, and some other people have gotten lucky.

2. The people who say they have had a problem are lying, or deceived.


3. The people who say they have a problem actually had a problem, but they a minority and got unlucky, and then extrapolated their experience to everyone else

The article actually ends with "shoppers are likely to find themselves disappointed and frustrated most of the time." - and that is clearly false for me and everyone I know. "rarely" or "occassionaly"? maybe. But not "most of the time".


> but they a minority and got unlucky, and then extrapolated their experience to everyone else

Bold of you to assume you're not the minority.


Don’t forget that “cashiers” aren’t a real job anyway, and with self checkout technology it allows someone who was a checker to be inspired to be a software engineer.

All they need to do is drop everything to learn one of the most competitive and hardest cross-disciplinary skills and jump into a shrinking market!


Not saying that they don't exist, but my experience has been nothing but positive. It must be 8-9 years since we got one locally, and it's been smooth sailing for me.

You scan the products. Confirm that you've scanned everything. Want a shopping bag, yes/no? Pay.

That's it. The scanners work. Payment work. Getting a receipt works.

Maybe I've just been lucky, who knows.


Why do you like it better than having a cashier ring you up?

Me: I don't have to scan, check I've scanned everything, enter the number of bags, put groceries in those bags. Instead I put my stuff on the belt, I pay and walk out w the groceries--and the cashier is a pro at scanning and bagging, whereas I am not.

Plus, it's not like these stores are going to pass along the labor savings to us. They'll just pocket the difference.


... after waiting in line for 20+ minutes

I remember the time before self-scan machines, and the lines were not shorter. Even "10 items or less" registers had huge lines.


Fair point--maybe the throughput is higher for self checkout. I still like not having to do the work myself tho.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: