Take capitalism out of it, do we really want to boil down intelligence to a calculation of expected economic value?
Why force the term intelligence into it at all if what were talking about is simply automation? We don't have to bastardize the term intelligence along the way, especially when we have spent centuries considering what human intelligence is and how it separates us from other species on the planet.
> Take capitalism out of it, do we really want to boil down intelligence to a calculation of expected economic value?
It's a lovely sentiment, but do you expect e.g. universities to start handing out degrees on the basis of human dignity rather than a series of tests whose ultimate purpose in our society is boiling down intelligence to a calculation of expected economic value?
We live in the world we live in and we have the measures we have. It's not about lofty ideals, it's about whether or not it can measurably do what a human does.
If I told you that my pillow is sentient and deserving of love and dignity, you have the choice of taking me at my word or finding a way to put my money where my mouth is. It's the same reason the world's best poker players aren't found by playing against each other with Monopoly money.
> Why force the term intelligence into it at all if what were talking about is simply automation?
In what world is modern AI "simply" anything?
> we have spent centuries considering what human intelligence is and how it separates us from other species on the planet.
Dolphins would like a word. There's more than a few philosophers who would argue that maybe our "intelligence" isn't so easily definable or special in the universe. There are zero successful capitalists who would pay my pillow or a dolphin to perform artificial intelligence research. That's what I mean when I call it the meaningful Turing test in a capitalist society. You can't just "take capitalism out of it." If I could just "take capitalism out" of anything meaningful I wouldn't be sitting here posting in this hell we're constructing. You may as well tell me to "take measurement out of it."
Why force the term intelligence into it at all if what were talking about is simply automation? We don't have to bastardize the term intelligence along the way, especially when we have spent centuries considering what human intelligence is and how it separates us from other species on the planet.