Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

iPhone messages app - where iMessage appears - is already interoperable with every other phone. SMS!



Sms is not end to end encrypted


RCS isn't either - it is a proprietary feature when using Google's client with Google's server.


Sure, but in practice, everyone's RCS is currently E2EE since everyone uses Google's client and Google's server.

This should change, certainly! Hopefully Apple will force Google to open up their implementation and protocol for E2EE so they can build a compatible implementation.


Maybe. The challenge with E2EE is how to resolve an email address or phone number to the authoritative public key and networking route, securely. If we wind up with multiple authoritative sources of that mapping, each one has the potential to lie and become an avenue for surveillance. Thats ignoring for the moment lesser issues, such as privacy issues with leaked metadata in querying these sources.

Things like Key Transparency in the IETF are tackling some of this, in the sense that they'll provide public evidence of tampering.

I don't suspect what Google has implemented for their own client/server setup gets us close to a multi-party solution within RCS Universal profile.


Neither is RCS without Google’s proprietary additions.


And?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: