Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It always strikes me as odd that the geoengineering experiment that got us into the predicament (dumping boatloads of CO2 into the atmosphere), the politics were so much easier.



I've generally come to the belief that it's related to how humans think about cause and effect.

Dumping boatloads of CO2 into the atmosphere is second order from the actual goal of producing electricity so most people just can't/don't/won't think about it.

In this case we'd be intentionally dumping SO2 so people are capable of thinking "wow that's not moral" or whatever issue they might have with it.


I think the biggest concern with something like releasing SO2 as a geoengineering project, which needs, quoting someone else in the thread "very little" to be released to have a big effect, the concern is over-correction or unforeseen effects caused by an insufficient understanding of the system as a whole.

Don't want to accidentally start an ice age by trying to prevent a hothouse planet from forming :P


And we want to stop releasing CO2. We don't want to wind up charging onwards to 1,000 ppm CO2 just because we released enough SO2 to compensate for the climate change.


Especially since human brains suffer significant cognitive effects above 1,000ppm.


Sounds like a self correcting problem to me. At what ppm levels are humans too stupid to support an industrial civilization? Full speed ahead...


Eh, don't worry, the rich among us will bottle up the 'good' air and, well, just watch the clip from the documentary "Spaceballs" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lz0xULQIaSU


"SnowPiercer" here we come...


The current predicament we are in was not produced by a deliberate attempt at global geoengineering. It was a global economic project with a byproduct of climate change.


It does not matter if someone screwed up my life on purpose or by accident, I am still harmed


I'd say that we need to discover a source of energy that produces SO2 as a byproduct, but given our species' track record we would probably trigger an ice-age in a few decades.


Hah!

Or maybe if some billionaire could figure out a way for their space-tourism project to “accidentally” produce SO2, then we’d give them the moral mulligan.


SO₂ was a byproduct of coal power stations, we started scrubbing it because it was the cause of acid rain.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: