Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"indistinguishable from ransomware" would be if you could pay google to free your data. Hyperbolic titles suck



I now ignore all Ron Amadeo articles on Ars. I don’t know where his disdain for Google originated but his predictably snarky dismissals of all things Google are just bad and lazy journalism.


This is the flipped script for our social contract with Google…they release product, they don’t have any obligation to care about users…dismissing us less loudly than the author, but no less real…


So..."worse than ransomware?"


Technically yes, but I suspect the ransomware comparison was brought up to paint how malicious it is. Otherwise the better analogy would be dropping your phone from 50ft.


Well, no, ransomware is worse than losing all data on the device, since ransomware gangs generally also destroy your backups and also attempt extortion with threats to publish your data. All backups help against accidental destruction and incidents like in this article, but for ransomware protection most cloud storage solutions won't help you, you need either offline or append-only backups.


from a data loss perspective, sure.

from an extortion perspective i'd rather have my data wiped.


You can pay extortionists to get your data back.

If your phone automatically factory resets, all the money in the world won’t recover your data…sadly worse than ransomware…


at least the randomware people have someone you can contact


I would rather have ransomware. At least paying would give you a chance to get the data back.


Well, NotPetya was a ransomware, yet paying wouldn't have decrypted any data.


Well, NotPetya obviously was not ransomware, it was malware that masqueraded to pretend to be ransomware.


That asks a question: is a malware defined by its intent, or by what it actually does? Functionally speaking, NotPetya was indistinguishable from a ransomware. It's creators intent however would make it a wiper.


It was actually a wiper.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: