Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Glad to hear it worked out for you. My kids school went full on Pi and they were broken and discarded after 2 months because they are mostly not suitable for educational settings from a software and hardware perspective. The hardware is not robust or reliable enough and the software requires fixing by staff too often to be productive.

Instead they taught them python on windows.




I’m surprised to hear that. We had an entire job tracking system in a large factory running off of them and they lasted years. This was with daily handling by factory workers.


I have a friend who has two children who are now allegedly young adults. They smash about one phone each per six months and one laptop screen each per three years. Their iPads are somehow intact, but dented to fuck. I, myself, broke a laptop screen when I was 16 (1999) by kneeling on it while it was open and concealed under my bedclothes. In the intervening 24 years, I have broken zero (0) laptop, desktop, PDA, or phone screens except by activities that I knew might result in their destruction (i.e. disassembly without proper tools under an understanding of 'either I manage to fix this right now or I order a new one and it arrives tomorrow’).

All this to say: kids are just rough on shit. They're inexperienced with potential failure modes and thus fail to anticipate what precautions might need to be taken in trying to avoid them. But they mostly grow up (after killing a few pieces of hardware).


Same here; multiple broken phone screens (and we're not buying him a new phone every time it breaks, he gets hand-me-downs at best), laptops (he managed to cram a power cable into the HDMI port in a panic, closed a laptop with probably something like a pen in between shearing the hinge, he probably punched it out of frustration / wanting a new one and blamed it on "some kids that used it as a shield"), multiple broken bikes, etc.


Crikey. Mine all have iPads and iPhones and have for a long time. They haven't broken anything yet!


I think the students are doing more "system integration" work than your factory workers are doing with their day-to-day handling. So they're touching all of the GPIO pins immediately after shuffling across the carpet to rub 18 balloons against themselves, connecting every GPIO pin to every other GPIO pin just for fun, rebooting by unplugging the power, etc.

If the Raspberry Pi had 5V compatible GPIO and SD cards stored data permanently immediately after fsync() returns, the Pi would have been much more successful in the educational environment.


While I can’t say my factory workers were keen on opening them up and poking around they did have a habit of hitting them with forklifts.


Imagine monkeys on meth and you basically have the school environment.


This speaks more to the competence of the educators than the technology itself.

In the right educators hands', the raspberry Pi can be used to bring generations of teenagers into computing competence.

You're only as good a student as your teacher.


No. You have a 2 hour window and 30 raspberry pi's. How long do you spend fixing them versus teaching?

It's just a fucking computer, not a world changing thing. They already have computers that don't have all the downsides but do have all of the upsides.


No. You have a 2 hour window and 30 raspberry pi's. How long do you spend fixing them versus teaching?

Fix that problem. Don't address it by introducing the kids to useless, proprietary technology.

It's just a fucking computer, not a world changing thing.

This irrational, entirely emotional attitude is also the problem. Its why kids can't code today, but could in the 80's.

Computers are world-changing things. This is why its so vital to teach kids properly and not chintz out on it because "its too hard".


With all due respect, computers have, and continue to be "world changing things".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: