Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

In the mid-late 2000's, Ardour (and a couple of other DAWs) had support for branching undo/redo histories.

We (Ardour) abandoned it, because the universal experience of non-programmers was that they had no idea how to even begin to use this sort of feature. The majority of DAW users don't come ready to deal with the complexities of a branching workflow, or even a desire to learn it.

There is at least one band out of Madison, WI that uses/used git with Ardour during the height of the pandemic to facilitate remote collaboration on new pieces. They gave a talk (and played) at the Ubuntu Summit in Prague last year.




That’s wild, super cool that you guys were trying to make that work so long ago. I can see how people unfamiliar with that way of thinking would be completely lost. Especially in the context of a daw which is basically a wall of buttons and switches.

As a very entrenched Reaper user, I haven’t tried Ardour, but I’m glad it exists and continues to exist. Thank you for your work :)


There are plenty of apps like Figma and Google Docs that have a kind collaboration and version control that non-programmers are able to understand.


I was specifically referring to branching workflows, not version control in general.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: