On: Argonne National Lab is attempting to replicate LK...

[cryptonector]

> Peer review is what happens when your peers ...

I would add: when your peers' review commentary is public.

[godelski → cryptonector]

I love when this happens tbh, but it is rather rare. Often I can tell that a paper was rejected for dumb reasons and that gives me a good signal to actually read it.

[xorbax → godelski]

Yeah, most of peer review is private

If journals posted first-submission comments for published papers I think there's be a radical change in comments. For good or ill, I have no idea.