Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The market of ideas fails under capitalism. The market of ideas is denominated in votes, but capitalism requires it to be denominated in dollars. The market of ideas also fails under governments and corporations who pay thousands of people to work covertly and overtly to eradicate ideas.



The problem isn't Capitalism. In Capitalism we can simply buy our services and anyone who can fund can play.

What is happening when a bank refuses to do business with someone, when App stores ban a twitter clone and prevent sideloading, is not Capitalism. It's ideological. It's about service to an end outside just capital.

Capitalism is the only system that freedom of speech can exist under. No Communist or Socialist author has ever entertained a freedom of speech concept - it is contrary to a centralized government. Such systems can not even handle mild political dissent and must (both in the theoretical and practical) literally kill or exile anyone pushing against the central authority.

Capitalism can always tolerate disagreement because disagreement is profitable.


>Capitalism can always tolerate disagreement because disagreement is profitable.

Eh, that depends. The US in particular like to 'two party' problems. Capitalism loves two sides in problems, but that is very problematic if a problem is multi-polar and not bi-polar.

You're also confusing socialist/communist with authoritarian. Capitalist systems are completely fine with being authoritarian if its profitable.


"No Communist or Socialist author has ever entertained a freedom of speech concept "

Maybe you have heard of Animal Farm or 1984, written by George Orwell?

Or do you think, he wrote those books to endorse the concept?


No authoritarian has entertained a concept of freedom of speech. Just so you're aware, yes, capitalist can be authoritarian too.


I don't get your point, do you claim Orwell is authorian and anti free speach?


The point is the converse: socialism can be liberal too, as exemplified by Orwell.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: