Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

No one is forcing you to install anything you don't want to. The only thing I want is having the ability to install anything I want to. If you don't want to install those things the solution is simple: Don't. You don't need Apple to make that decision for you.



While I wish I lived in a world of perfect competition, I also realize that I don't. System-wide rules against bad behavior are a lot more efficient.

> You don't need Apple to make that decision for you.

I also don't need an app making the decision of whether I need an account. Apple preserves that choice for users. And they're not making any decisions for the user about installing. Effectively zero apps will leave the store over this rule, so the user retains full choice over installing.


> System-wide rules against bad behavior are a lot more efficient.

I don't want Apple making many system-wide rules on behavior, even on Apple's own systems (which they share with their users.)

That being said, they're very right about this. Making the distinction between, on one side, apps that are useless without accounts (like banking apps) or apps that are made to help with already existing accounts, and on the other side apps that are just forcing accounts to capture and control the users, is a smart and thoughtful move.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: