Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

One of the things I think of when I see autonomous quadrotors is a localized missile defense shield.

A swarm of disposable quadrotors surrounding a ship, set on a rotating recharge schedule, that intercept missiles and detonate a small explosive payload.




Unfortunately, I agree. From the first time I saw this technology the top application that jumped off the page to me was of a military nature. Perhaps a day will come when this may not be so. Until that day comes, tech like this, I believe, will save lives; on and off the battlefield.


Save lives, or cost lives (or both), depending on who's in charge and what their aims are.


The scariest part of inventing/innovation; the realization that what one creates may fall into the hands of those with aims that are less than noble...


These things might be too slow to intercept an incoming missile, especially the super sonic ones. The quadrotor doesn't look like very energy efficient. There are 4 rotors to draw energy. They must need to recharge pretty quick. With a large number of them, the energy draw from the ship is pretty demanding.


>With a large number of them, the energy draw from the ship is pretty demanding.

There are destroyers on the drawing board with enough excess capacity to power rail guns, and the latest aircraft carriers have upgraded reactor units to power the electromagnetic launch systems they use instead of steam catapults.

The reactors that supply these large ships should have plenty of excess power for a few hundred drones.

>These things might be too slow to intercept an incoming missile, especially the super sonic ones.

They don't have to match speed, they just need to place themselves in the path of the missile; they are incredibly agile and shouldn't have trouble doing so.


How would this have any advantage over a defensive system like Phalanx?


It would be much harder to overwhelm with multiple missiles.

You have to place Phalanx systems all around the ship in order to provide 360 degree protection. However, an enemy could concentrate multiple missiles on a space covered by only 1 Phalanx.

If radar detects multiple missiles inbound, more drones could be easily be routed to the appropriate area to intercept. To overwhelm the defense you'd have to fire more missiles than the ship has drones (and since drones could be made much more cheaply than supersonic missiles, that would be fairly hard to do).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: