Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

So John Gruber is basically an official Apple announcement channel now?



I think we might be seeing is Apple acknowledging that journalists are going to have "blind men and an elephant"[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blind_men_and_an_elephant] problems, and arranging to have a sufficient number of blind men feel the elephant to get the whole description, and all tell their stories at once only makes sense.

You've got Gruber talking about only on the most visible features, but spending more thought on corporate communication strategy and iCloud directions.

Jason Snell articulates new features as clearly as I'd expect from an Apple "New in Mountain Lion" page.

Edward Mendelson I think covers even more features, but not as clearly as Jason Snell, and I think his vision of "AirPlay display to TV" -> "Mac is video game console" is fatally doomed by latency.[1] But it's ok. We have enough people touching the elephant and describing it to dilute that.

So here you have the new strategy for non-event announcements. Arrange for simultaneous views from multiple, competent sources. Let the first sounds in the echo chamber be accurate and well informed to keep the erroneous speculation to a minimum.

EOM

[1] I could also be wrong here. With gigabit 802.11ac just around the corner, one could conceive of a TV device that optimized the latency from wifi to screen. You know, by tearing apart the industry's entrenched model and doing their own vision. But I'm just groping an elephant here.


Well, MG Siegler managed to get access to Chrome for Android before it was public and he's hardly a Google fanboy.


It's being announced all over the place.


The difference is that other journalists who got the preview also write about other products, whereas Gruber only writes about Apple.

When an Apple-exclusive blog gets preferential treatment and news scoops directly from Apple, it's reasonable to ask whether it's anything more than Phil Schiller's astroturfing outlet.


You could say the same about MacWorld.


Being compared to MacWorld is hardly an endorsement of an independent blogger's journalistic integrity.


But it is rather odd to complain that getting a briefing to a "biased" reporter is unusual. It's like Thurott getting briefed on Windows stuff, S.O.P.


As someone who has Gruber's musings on baseball pop up all over his twitter and RSS clients, I'm inclined to disagree.


Gruber is not at all Apple exclusive, but he is clearly a fan.


I suspect he isn't the only one that got this treatment, though it would be amusing if he was (and I'm sure it will cause a big kerfuffle).


Gruber has a rabid following of hardcore apple lovers. Just the kind of people who are going to be most interested in these announcements. They would be dumb not to get him involved in this type of release (which I think we'll see more of in the future).


He probably believes in every word he writes, but Apple sure seems him as one channel.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: