> Do you realize that page was established in 2013?
No, but that makes sense. The framing would have been much more apt back then than it is now, with the Snowden stuff being fresh.
> If the reference is keeping all your messages, and potentially your PGP keys, in "cloud" storage at a PRISM provider it's not particularly hard to understand some ways in which using Thunderbird instead is supposed to help. It's a fair point it's not a particularly satisfying mitigation though.
The reference is just "instead of Gmail, use Thunderbird" (e.g. https://prism-break.org/en/subcategories/macos-email/). They don't mention PGP in that section at all, though there's a later one about "Email Addons, which does, which is easy to miss (e.g. skipping b/c you don't already use addons).
Their (broken HTML) recommendation to run your own email email server is also suspect, because it's a bad tradeoff. Unless you want a second, unpaid job as email server administrator (with a pager!), you're "protecting" yourself against a rare hypothetical threat (government surveillance) by making yourself vulnerable to a much more common one (run of the mill hackers).
Realistically, they probably should have just said something along the lines of "email surveillance is practically unavoidable," so don't use it for anything you don't want monitored. PGP failed because it's too hard to use, so no one uses it, and any reasonable use of email will mainly involve exchanging messages with some "monitored provider's" servers.
No, but that makes sense. The framing would have been much more apt back then than it is now, with the Snowden stuff being fresh.
> If the reference is keeping all your messages, and potentially your PGP keys, in "cloud" storage at a PRISM provider it's not particularly hard to understand some ways in which using Thunderbird instead is supposed to help. It's a fair point it's not a particularly satisfying mitigation though.
The reference is just "instead of Gmail, use Thunderbird" (e.g. https://prism-break.org/en/subcategories/macos-email/). They don't mention PGP in that section at all, though there's a later one about "Email Addons, which does, which is easy to miss (e.g. skipping b/c you don't already use addons).
Their (broken HTML) recommendation to run your own email email server is also suspect, because it's a bad tradeoff. Unless you want a second, unpaid job as email server administrator (with a pager!), you're "protecting" yourself against a rare hypothetical threat (government surveillance) by making yourself vulnerable to a much more common one (run of the mill hackers).
Realistically, they probably should have just said something along the lines of "email surveillance is practically unavoidable," so don't use it for anything you don't want monitored. PGP failed because it's too hard to use, so no one uses it, and any reasonable use of email will mainly involve exchanging messages with some "monitored provider's" servers.