Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> I still think that Apple's dictatorial grip on their platforms broadly stifles innovation and has a negative impact on competition.

If that’s the case, where is all of the “innovation” on Android that average consumers would care about?




Consider that for an experience to exist _at all_ on iOS, the developer must pay an additional 30% tax to Apple - that's on top of other cost burdens.

It's not simply an advertising premium for the App Store - it's a license to run your software on their platform period (not dissimilar to console games).

If someone wanted to produce a competitor to Netflix, YouTube, Spotify, Uber and the like - their startups could never be cost competitive on iOS because they wouldn't operate at the same scale as competitors.

The argument of "what more could you want from your device that the mega corps don't already provide" ignores the fact that you'll never know what you're missing out on because those products never got off the ground.

I'm not saying iOS is bad, it's that Apple isn't incentivised to create a marketplace that encourages competition, instead they actively hinder things that would make their platform richer for the user.

The market has demonstrated that success is contingent on such practices. Without regulators stepping in to change the rules of play, it's unlikely we will see an environment less hostile towards competition in digital products/services.


> If someone wanted to produce a competitor to Netflix, YouTube, Spotify, Uber and the like - their startups could never be cost competitive on iOS because they wouldn't operate at the same scale as competitors.

Netflix and Spotify haven’t allowed in app purchases for years and don’t give Apple any “cut”. Uber doesn’t use in app purchases. It gives you the option of using Apple Pay which charges standard credit card rates.

Again, if it’s only Apple, why wouldn’t all of these “innovations” be happening on Android.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: