Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Eich being a homophobe

Wut? Citation needed. I’m sure you don’t mean his support of Proposition 8 in 2008, because Barack Obama professed the same belief in 2008… making him, in this formulation, a homophobe.




I don't think we need an umpteenth discussion about this here, it has already been discussed to hell. This is getting old. Just search Brendan Each on HN [1], this discussion happens any time he is mentioned here.

Or just read the summary on Wikipedia [2].

There's a lot of material on this topic, it's easy to make up one's opinion on this if you are genuinely interested.

edit: please people, don't feed this.

[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brendan_Eich#Appointment_to_CE...


As a bi man, the next paragraphs excuse nothing.

But if these details are to play a factor in browser selection, one should reflect on the myriad of undesirable associations involved in going about daily life.

Just typing this reply involves an entire supply chain associated with individuals and organizations of questionable character.

To apply this same level of sensitivity to daily life would be to mostly unhook oneself from modern society.

I care deeply about the safety and freedom of the LGBTQ+ community, and find little value in allowing someone else’s lack of acceptance of me dictate my life. Doing so is a form of “doing something” that does nothing but widen the gap to actual change, which can only ever happen via open dialogue.

I think there are plenty of reasons not to choose Brave based on the actual technical merits of the product.


Sure, I'm not disagreeing with you and this is actually an interesting philosophical topic to discuss (I mean it, I'm genuinely interested in this and have been wondering where to put limits on this kind of stuff).

But wondering whether is Eich homophobic? Meh. Bored of these discussions. I have set my opinion on this. It's been discussed enough.


Yeah, that’s a fair stance and I generally agree with you here.


What are your thoughts on Chick-Fil-A. I will sometimes choose them on the merits of their product.


I tend to avoid fast food in general, but I try not to orient my life around actions (or avoiding actions) that are unlikely to have any impact, especially if they involve spending more of my own energy.

Avoiding Chik-Fil-A at all costs: primarily affects me.

Being willing to frequent a Chik-Fil-A because a friend somewhere else on the political spectrum enjoys it: potentially opens an opportunity to talk.

Most of my family and their circles fit that latter description, so this is not a hypothetical. Any chance of influencing them is actively harmed by choosing/avoiding fast food based on tribal allegiance.

None of this should be construed to mean that I find their leadership team and public stances acceptable.


That has nothing to do with my comment. You libeled someone without providing any proof at all.


> That has nothing to do with my comment

It has everything to do with your comment? I'm inviting anybody interested on the topic to go read about it themselves instead of rehashing the same subject again and again, since I believe everything about this has already been said already?

> You libeled someone without providing any proof at all.

On the contrary, please notice how I carefully and deliberately stated nothing about Eich, not given my opinion on this and not taken sides here.

It would not be smart, it would invite people who have opinions on this to further push this discussion.

Did you confuse me with another commenter?


Yes! Apologies. I did indeed answer the wrong comment.


so someone being against gay marriage is not a homophobe in your eyes? Why can't Obama just also be/have been a homophobe


One can have a principled opposition to gay marriage without being a homophobe.

Declaring someone else is a homophobe without their making such an assertion is mindreading.


> One can have a principled opposition to gay marriage without being a homophobe.

The same way a principled vegan also eats meat, to be sure.


actions speak louder than words. by that logic you can never declare anyone anything.


No, they can’t.


Barack Obama opposed prop 8 in 2008, and certainly never donated money to the campaign like Eich did. There are dozens of articles about it.

But he also opposed gay marriage, so to some extent he was homophobic, at least for political reasons. He later changed his mind on it, likely also for political reasons.

But shame on you for using such disingenuous bullshit tactics to make your homophobic point: “If you call Eich a homophobe, then you also have to call <insert beloved liberal figure> a homophobe!”. For one, it ignores the fact that people’s minds can change over time, whereas Eich has never changed his stance on gay marriage and has never disavowed the money he spent trying to stop it. And two, it’s just a red herring argument and attempted hypocrisy trap.

And worse, it’s a fucking terrible hypocrisy trap. There are millions of people who support gay marriage but never supported Barack Obama, and millions more who supported Obama precisely because they didn’t want gay marriage and thought they could trust him to not change his mind on it. Obama may be beloved by some liberals, but he is a hypocrite to many on a multitude of reasons, ranging from his gay marriage flip flop, to his support of the patriot act, to the promotion of indefinite detention and torture to federal law, to the fact that he continued the pointless Iraq war for his entire term.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: