Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Risky move, given that Georgia is a constitutional carry state and castle doctrine extends to occupied vehicles.



Risky move, given that Georgia is a constitutional carry state and castle doctrine extends to occupied vehicles.

Not really. By the time a seat-belted person gets to their gun, whether in a holster, under the seat, in a purse, or in the glove box, the thief is long gone.

Real life is very different from the movies.


You are asserting that it takes a long time to get a gun out.

I remember a few years back there was some controversy about how police are trained to shoot first and one of the things that bubbled up then was a video (I think produced by someone teaching the police) of a seated driver drawing a gun and having it pointed out the window in a fraction of a second. The gun was in a holster down by the seat belt buckle. And the next instant it was pointing out the driver's window.


Makes sense for a seasoned criminal, of the type who might shoot a cop.

Joe Lunchbucket isn't likely to be so agile.


Statistically speaking, Joe Lunchbucket, is likely a better trained shooter than the police, most of whom only fire their guns once a year to qualify and have to meet lower accuracy standards than CHL holders in 32 states.


Why risky? Assuming the person with the rock knows this and is armed, they're probably ready for a would-be Rambo and they're much better positioned to shoot first, or at least they'll have the draw and be able to take your gun right off of you.


Im pretty sure most guns are owned by hoarders sitting in a cabinet somewhere they aren’t likely to be in someone’s car who is ready to use it. Gun owners are a minority and they are just very enthusiastic individuals that they seem like a larger contingent than they are.


In 2020 this poll found 32% of Americans report owning a gun, and 44% live in a household with one. So not "most", but not insubstantial either.

https://news.gallup.com/poll/264932/percentage-americans-own...


Mine is in my truck. So that's 1 data point.


there are over 400 million firearms in the US in the hands of an estimated 100 million individuals

over two million background checks for firearms purchases are performed each month, and this number is rising, and the number of people who are being background checked for the first time is rapidly rising (fastest growing group - black women)

by 2030 there will likely be a half billion firearms in the US

there are more fully automatic rifles registered to individuals in Texas (40k) than are in possession of many NATO armies...for semi-auto pistols and rifles, Texas residents outgun most NATO armies by a substantial margin

these are stats that both gun advocacy and opposition groups will be happy to validate (each believe the numbers support their position)

anecdotally, it is very common here in Texas to read of traffic altercations in which both parties involved in road rage incidents were carrying in their vehicles...it is widespread


Posted elsewhere but https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3937627 has numbers to back some of this up

Also according to the Small Arms Survey, Texas has five times as many guns as the US military.

Though the US military ones are more likely to have select fire and fully automatic but those are only particularly useful in certain situations.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: