Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's terrible for the workers, because currently they get overtime pay beyond 9 hours, this law effectively reduces overtime by 3 hours. Women also play a bigger role in running the household, and with 12-hour shifts plus commute time, this must take a big toll on the family.



Well family is the last thing on mind for Economic planners and political class. They have this cartoonish belief that they can beat China by having worse labor laws on workers' welfare.


> they have this cartoonish belief that they can beat China by having worse labor laws on workers' welfare.

Is it really cartoonish when everyone apparently agrees that China became what it is today by having worse labour laws then the rest of the world?


Plenty of countries had even worse labour laws. Worse labour laws than, say, the USA and Western Europe, sure, but India is already there.


These are - relatively - good jobs, right?


Not particularly.

You're earning around $2.5k a year (1.8 lpa) which isn't the most competitive even in most of India tbh, especially when factoring CoL in Karnataka. If this was Andhra Pradesh, Rajasthan, or Harit Pradesh/Western UP (regions of India with the right mix of supply chain and cheap labor), it might fly with migrants from Bihar, Purvanchal, and the Tribal Belt, but definetly not in KN.

You can easily earn that much in farming, or via alternative unskilled labor with better work hours (eg. street food stalls, MGNREGA, etc).


1.8 lpa is better than what many "uskilled" labourers make even in Karnataka. 1.1 to 1.44 lpa (9k to 12k a month) is what the cleaners, for example, makes in a college where someone I know studies. Daily wage labourers make a similar amount.


True! But cleaners and mazdoori labourers make that much for better hours.

Also the 1.8lpa figure is for their "Graduate Engineering Trainee" - for assembly Foxconn began leveraging Engineering graduates to work in assembly. So this isn't an unskilled job, and even then pay is on the lower end for a fresher.

That's why there was a violent bandh a couple years ago at a Foxconn supplier named Winstron - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NqvT8LYj2Ic - bad pay and bad hours pissed workers off.


They would be better if each person worked fewer hours so more people could have jobs and demand higher pay.


I don’t think these jobs are making them rich. No need to relativize a socially backward policy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: