On: Hardware microphone disconnect (2021)

[iamspoilt]

Does that mean MacBook microphone cannot work while operating in Dock mode?

[havefunbesafe → iamspoilt]

Imagine how terribly it would work, given that the mic is adjacent to the speakers.

[amf12 → iamspoilt]

This is an interesting use case that is worth mentioning. This feature would make MacBook unusable for me unless I use a Bluetooth headset.

[jaysinn_420 → iamspoilt]

Yes, that is exactly what it means.

[iLoveOncall → iamspoilt]

Yes, and it's incredibly annoying.

[mrtksn → iLoveOncall]

I guess this fits the situation: https://xkcd.com/1172/

It probably wouldn't work well due to the obstruction anyway.

[iLoveOncall → mrtksn]

No it doesn't. The sound plays just fine when the computer is closed, why would the microphone stop?

You are able to use an external monitor with your laptop closed, it's not an edge case to want to use the computer's mic in that case.

[mrtksn → iLoveOncall]

It's not just fine, it's degraded quality because these are directional beam forming microphones.