Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Making it illegal does not make it go away. Like racisim has not ended. They need to bring in reservations in education and govt jobs, a strong act like the sc/st act to ensure marginalized people get their due.



It does give you recourse if it does happen though and over time it at least gets quieter and more subtle. If we'd applied this same logic to the Civil Rights Act in the 60s we would be much further behind where we've made it to today.


Sarcasm right? America has to import and litigate all of the world's problems? White Man's Burden?


> They need to bring in reservations in education and govt jobs

No that would be idiotic because most of the time the discrimination has nothing to do with Caste.

Different areas of india have completely different cultures (languages, foods, customs, etc.)

Most of the discrimination is based on where you're from (do you speak tamil vs. hindi vs gujarati...)

People want to hire people who are similar to them. Chasing caste is the wrong issue.

India has thousands of years of cultural history & practices. America has...250 years?

Applying your mental models from American politics to India (which is far more complicated) and then forming a strong opinion (without knowing anything about indian culture) is hilariously idiotic.

There's far more things indian discriminate on other than caste. Location, language, family group, language-spoken, wealth, etc. And obviously political views.

Half the time you have no idea what caste someone is.


That's just institutionalized racism, but literally.


Yup, because that works out really well in India...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: