Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The government won't forbid the sale of transistors and solder. They don't have to, for two reasons.

Firstly, nobody can build a computer to the standard of a contemporary desktop out of transistors and solder. It simply can't be done, even if you don't care about its size or power consumption. You can build a little 4-bit computer, but that's no use to you. So they don't have to prevent all unsecured computation, they just have to prevent you doing more than, say, a billion cycles of computation.

Second, even if the bar is much lower than that — say, you can buy all the chips you need, you just can't buy them preassembled into circuit boards — that's already an effective suppression of general purpose computation. Maybe you personally have the skills and the time to build a computer from those pieces, but I and most people don't. So I've been effectively prevented from computation. I won't write programs and post them on the net, and the online programming communities will dwindle to a small bunch of experts.

And once almost nobody builds or uses general-purpose computers, it's much easier for the government to say "We can't think of a legitimate reason you need a computer, therefore, anyone who has one is a terrorist/pirate/communist." QED.




The only devices I am aware of that are regulated to the point of "you must assemble them yourself" are hand grenades and fully automatic weapons.

It may just be me, but I don't think our society views general purpose computers as quite that dangerous.


Yet.


I wouldn't say that society views industrial quantities of fertilizer as dangerous, but the FBI keeps track of who's buying it.


Industrial quantities of fertilizer IS dangerous. The Oslo bombing wasn't even that long ago, have you forgotten?


You missed my point. Of course it's dangerous if you want it to be, but so is a kitchen knife.

The point is, stuff eventually gets regulated because of how it might be used, not because of how it's normally used.


But is fertilizer actually regulated?


Apparently yes: http://cnsnews.com/news/article/fertilizer-control-dhs-creat...

(Thanks for making me research it, I learned some interesting stuff and I would learn more if I had more time.)


99.9% (and probably a few more 9's) of Fertilizer sold in Industrial Quantities is used on farms and not really all that dangerous.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: