Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They allowed you to buy the "car can drive itself" capability and never fully delivered. It's not like this was just a promise, it was something you could pay for years ago.



Yeah, but that isn't a crime. You can pre-order things. They still claim they will deliver it. Seems like maybe you could do a class-action or something to get your money back, but not argue that actually it was reasonable to believe you already had it and therefore are not liable for a crash or whatever.


> Yeah, but that isn't a crime. You can pre-order things.

It actually is. When accepting a preorder you have to provide a fixed delivery date, or it is assumed to be no later than 30 days after sale (or 50 days if you offer in-house financing). The fraud case here is actually very straightforward.

https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/business-gui...


IANAL but I think you could call it fraud if you never had any intention of delivering. E.g. if I kickstart a perpetual motion machine and then move to the Bahamas with the funds.

What's ironic is that despite his image as a genius no one ever holds Elon to account for his failure to accurately predict the state/progress of his own technology. He's either not as smart as people think or he's knowingly lying, but I think you have to pick one.


Seems like since they are delivering things, albeit slowly, and spending tons of money developing it, that it would be hard to make that stick.


Yeah, probably true.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: