Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is one of those statements which are true only if you live in California.

A 5-6 year old EV battery is unusable in winter at low-ish temperatures. Not only do you lose range when parked, you can be in real trouble if you’re stranded in a snowstorm.

These issues are manageable with a new car of course!




> This is one of those statements which are true only if you live in California.

I definitely don't live in California.

> A 5-6 year old EV battery is unusable in winter at low-ish temperatures.

A brand new EV gets less range in winter. A used EV gets less range in winter. A used EV in winter gets less range still.

But that doesn't make it unusable, it just changes the use case. A 300km range (when new) EV might reliably get 50% range in winter, and 70% range when 6 years old, combining for 35% of new range when used and in winter - plenty of buffer for an average driver's commute, but wouldn't want to use it for a winter road trip.

> you lose range when parked

Same applies whether it's a new EV or a used. If I were driving an EV in the winter (gets to -20C here regularly), I'd definitely be looking to park somewhere I could plug in - which are pretty common. As is, I drive an ICE, and I have to turn my car on for a few minutes to warm the engine before I start driving (or else the windshield becomes an unusable fogged-up mess before the end of the block)

> you can be in real trouble if you’re stranded in a snowstorm.

Yes, monitoring weather is important regardless of your vehicle choice. The only time I've been stuck in a snowstorm was when knowingly going for a weekend camping trip when a blizzard was forecast. (the solution was bring extra food in case we got stuck)

> These issues are manageable with a new car of course!

Or used. It's all about anticipating a situation.


ICEs have less range in winter too and you're always in trouble if you're stranded in a snowstorm.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: