Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Yeah car dealer arson, allrighty. Did you notice that two deep sea major pipelines have been blown up recently? Do you think that compares?

>Yeah right, you see the difference between chain store arson and blowing a deep-sea pipeline now that I'm pointing it to you?

The reasonable conclusion to draw from that would be "this pipeline explosion wasn't caused by eco-terrorists because eco-terrorists aren't radical enough to bomb gas pipelines", not "it wasn't caused by eco-terrorists can only be funded by public donations and they don't want to piss off their donor base".

>Do you intend to mean that such grassroots orgs would not need PR nor donations?

1. Al-Qaeda has PR (think grainy videos, not slick NY PR firm) and received donations[1], but I wouldn't characterize them as the same type of organization as greenpeace or whatever.

2. during ELF's existence, do you think they operated like a regular charity?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Qaeda#Financing

>Then no because grassroots organisations that would not raise donations do not have enough funds to blow a deepsea pipeline.

The wikipedia article also mentions someone being able to procure a RPG-7 from some sort of terrorist organization to launch at a nuclear power plant. Given that it doesn't seem too implausible that a group can acquire a boat and some depth charges without having to run a nationwide fundraising campaign.




The pipeline operation would require rich individuals, presumably educated, a fortiori if they are so invested in ecology. Do you think they would release millions of tons of CO2-equivalent of methane in the air?

Moreover they would need a large team to prepare and execute the op.

No-one on the team would say like "hu? isn't it a bit destroying that what we are fighting for?". Don't you think at least a dozen of potential whistleblowers would pop up into existence and the whole project aborted?

So, no, my verdict is that all of that is so unlikely. I'm trying very hard to not say ridiculous but... oops.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: