Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Do we actually have effective strategies for dealing with significant over-generation? The author glosses over it as being necessary to get to 98% renewables throughout the year ("we'll just run our hydro dams in reverse"), but I'm under the impression that over-generation that is unhandled leads to grid instability/desync.



PV can be throttled instantly to anything down to 0. Otherwise no offgrid setup would be feasible.

You can mandate smart control signals to PV inverters or don't do anything and let the frequency go up so even inverters installed today will start cutting power as this is a requirement from grid code.

Wind has a bigger lag (seconds) but it has brakes to save them in storms.

So those are easy problems (technologically).


It's better to use price signals to ratchet demand up if you can.

The UK already has a tariff that can warn you about upcoming periods of free power. Electric car users like it. They like it a lot.


I have a contract that uses nordpool spot market prices that are known ahead for each hour for the next day. I have PV on my roof and an EV. The price volatility is just insane between 2 and 4000 EUR/MWh so 2000x in the last week alone. So I finally connected a smallish house battery (about 14kWh) last week and by purely arbitrage I’ve made about 100 euros in the week. Even with an 8kW feed in cap and such a tiny battery.


Is over generation an issue that needs to be solved beyond disconnection from the grid?

Gas and Petrol Plants are commonly run in stand by mode because the ramp down/up times are too great to take them off line.


Stop some of the wind generators. Disconnect some of the solar panels. Both are standard practice today.


I think wind and solar can simply be turned off if need be.


Maybe folding@home; desalination for farming; pumping and spraying water to re-glaciate areas in the winter.


Resistively heated thermal storage for any industrial plant that uses process heat.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: