Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't forsee Intel support, but M2 support will come. They're just slowly rolling this out.

> Would be better if they pull their opposition for "right to repair".

But then you'd be in the same position you are now with Apple where you'd just get the individual parts and fuck your computer up.

Though maybe they should pull their opposition (if indeed they are opposed to this for no good reason) so then companies would have to support the right to repair products like dSLR cameras, TVs and computer monitors, Nintendo Switches, and Samsung mobile phones. I think this would be a nice little market advantage for Apple since these companies are fucking terrible at support for products beyond "send it in". Can you imagine Google trying to support repairing a Chromebook? Though I think what you'd find is just more throw-away electronics because a screen for a Chromebook individually purchased and sent to you will probably cost half as much as a new one. Good for the environment there.

Another thing I wonder about is should we treat personal electronics differently? There's a lot of focus on them but most are cheap and disposable. I think there's significant issues with manufacturing or industrial scale products like the infamous John Deere tractors that you can't fix yourself.




My niece broke the screen on her dirt cheap Chromebook. A Samsung Chromebook 3. I bought her a new screen for about $30 and was able to replace it myself in about 5 minutes after watching a short Youtube howto.

The Lenovo Chromebook 3 seems to be similar. I bought one during the recent $79 sale. Was curious if I could DIY an upgrade to an IPS screen. Found some screens that looked like a good fit for around $40 and the screen is easily user serviceable. There's many videos on how to fix various aspects of this ultra cheap laptop, and Lenovo has an easily downloaded service manual.


Then what's the issue? Apparently we already have right to repair in practice. Or is specifically that people want to be able to do this with Macbooks and iPhones? Vote with your wallet then.


Not enough. Right to repair should be mandated by law, because throwing away perfectly good hardware damages our planet, so it is not just a matter of the money exchanged between the producer and the customer.


Then don't throw away your hardware? The person I'm responding to didn't. Would you also mandate recycling? I'd certainly support that. I'm just not sure what a right to repair law is addressing here that's different than what's currently happening. I would hypothesize that mandatory recycling would go further in effect than right to repair.


> Then don't throw away your hardware?

No you see the world is black or white.

So either you can repair it yourself or it has to be thrown out.

Definitely no way to take it to Apple or a third party repairer to have it fixed.


I was responding to your mention of Chromebooks and how expensive you thought they would be to fix. And also because I thought it was interesting that these two very cheap gadgets were easily fixable. I guess since the main customers for these cheap laptops are schools, they'd have to be repairable. School budgets would almost mandate their hardware acquisitions be cheaply repairable instead of having to replace the entire unit. Especially when they hand these things out to accident prone kids.

But we don't have right to repair across the board. Would be nice if manufacturers took this into account.


To nitpick a bit I was more so criticizing what I envision Google's support for repairing these devices to be. More from an infrastructure/customer support perspective. I did mention that these devices were inexpensive and I would guess that for most people they'd prefer to throw the device away instead of repair it given our current cultural climate.

Now I do not have a lot of experience fixing devices, I tend to use and then either gift old devices to family members or recycle them, but I am curious about how much more repairable one of these devices is compared to, say, a new Macbook Pro. Also I wonder if current state is indicative of future state. For all we know Apple might make repair and upgrade of devices a top priority. Certainly they're showing some serious movement here in my opinion.


I think repair rights for Asus/Samsung Chromebook should be cared by Asus/Samsung rather than Google even though it's named "Chromebook", just like Windows laptops.


Sure that's fair. Replace Chromebook with Nest products and Pixel products such as phones and earbuds.


> Can you imagine Google trying to support repairing a Chromebook?

iFixit has Chromebook guides. Hobbyist communities and niche boutique repair shops arise to fit the needs.

https://www.ifixit.com/Search?query=chromebook


They have them for Macs and iPhones too, and there are a lot of device repair shops for their products.

https://www.ifixit.com/Device/MacBook_Pro


unless google recently bought out ifixit, not seeing the relevance to the statement




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: