Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



What increased enmity are you referring to? Similar to the War on Christmas and other talking points, I never experience any of this.


Official hate speech policies and enforcement patterns on Reddit, Facebook and Twitter explicitly allow racist speech that targets whites. Facebook:

https://reason.com/volokh/2020/12/07/facebook-discriminating...

>In the first phase of the project, which was announced internally to a small group in October, engineers said they had changed the company's systems to deprioritize policing contemptuous comments about "whites," "men" and "Americans." Facebook still considers such attacks to be hate speech, and users can still report it to the company. However, the company's technology now treats them as "low-sensitivity"—or less likely to be harmful—so that they are no longer automatically deleted by the company's algorithms.

Twitter's stated policies are better, but they allow this kind of slander in practice:

https://twitter.com/AyannaPressley/status/129878054043122483...

Reddit:

https://reclaimthenet.org/reddit-hate-speech-majority-groups...

>While the rule on hate protects such groups, it does not protect all groups or all forms of identity. For example, the rule does not protect groups of people who are in the majority

Historically, Reddit in particular hosted extremely hateful subreddits against black people and other minorities. It seems they decided to correct this by inverting rather than eliminating racial bias. This is not a long-term recipe for social cohesion.

For anecdata, see most online media of the past ten years:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FacehMiXEAAAO9d?format=jpg&name=...

University professors like Rutger's Brittney Cooper saying "I think that white people are committed to being villains in the aggregate", and "we got to take these motherf-ckers out:"

https://nypost.com/2021/10/29/rutgers-professor-calls-white-...

That was a year ago, she still has her job and none but conservative outlets seemed to care:

https://africanastudies.rutgers.edu/faculty-mainmenu-134/cor...


"They don't censor reverse racism as badly" is a far cry from what you are alleging. It sounds like Facebook realized they were overmoderating and backed down.

And, furthermore, I would rather tech giants err on the side of less censorship. The problem that they've engendered over the past decade is that they want to punish everyone rather than just dealing with narrow problems. If you realize your platform is being used for, say, harassment; you don't need to impose stricter speech rules. You need to make it harder to use your platform to harass people and provide meaningful support to those who have been harassed. They didn't really... do that. They imposed broad "whatever pisses off our advertisers" policies.

Related note: Reddit did not correct their racism problem. In fact, site administration has explicitly intervened to prohibit operators of such subreddits from closing them down (such as in the case of /r/KotakuInAction). The only time they ever bother enforcing their own rules is when those subs become enough of a problem that investors or advertisers get cold feet.


>And, furthermore, I would rather tech giants err on the side of less censorship.

Agreed, but censoring some hate speech less than others is worse than uniform censorship.

>The only time they ever bother enforcing their own rules is when those subs become enough of a problem that investors or advertisers get cold feet.

Yes, and investors today don't get cold feet about racial hatred of whites, or Reddit would alter their official policies accordingly.


Look no further than the rest of the comments on this post explaining how Jordan was wrong.


Sounds like you got a persecution complex if you believe whites are receiving any real hostility in the US. But comments like this don't surprise me anymore on HN. HN is surprisingly conservative. I guess lots of rich white people here, and lots of people who want to be a rich white person.


The correct response to flamebait on HN is always just to flag it and move on.

This isn't Reddit - just elect the thread for removal to keep the conversation productive and healthy.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: