Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I would argue that linux and macos are the most popular.

And its really not my problem if you think a unix has to be mono..thats just wrong and you know it.




> And its really not my problem if you think a unix has to be mono..thats just wrong and you know it.

It's not really my problem if you think I said UNIX has to be a monolith, since I never said that.

Xv6 is a reimplementation based on the original v6 UNIX design. As a teaching tool for the historical design of UNIX, it's a great place to start. If you want to study Unix-like microkernels, then MINIX and Tanenbaum's books are a great place to start.

If you want to study hybrid Unix-like systems, then the Darwin source code might be a good place to start. MacOS as a popular, hybrid, desktop Unix is pretty much an anomaly in the course of Unix history.

Study whatever you want, but for beginners to OS design, it's easier to understand hybrid and microkernel systems if you first know what a monolithic kernel is, and how various modern versions of Unix evolved from that in my personal opinion.

Nobody really gives a rat's ass about UNIX certification in the real world ... except MacOS fans.


>It's not really my problem if you think I said UNIX has to be a monolith, since I never said that.

Sure you said that:

>Right - for a start xv6 is a monolithic kernel, and MINIX is (mostly) not.

>Nobody really gives a rat's ass about UNIX certification in the real world ... except MacOS fans.

Then don't call it Unix, your a liar and i stop here.


I would argue MINIX is the most popular… as it runs in every Intel CPU.


I hear this a lot - but given that consumer choice is pretty much taken out of the equation, I don't really consider popularity to be applicable. People don't buy Intel CPU's because of the Minix ME.


That argument is just stupid...see smartphone rt-os in gsm chips, and btw it runs intel-me, not the chip. You can remove/disable it.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: