Otherwise brilliant and rational people just go all mystical when we start talking about meaningless words like “intelligence” or “consciousness”.
An animal or a human or a big matrix perform X well on Y task. That’s quantitative and objective.
All this “is it smart” bullshit is thinly-veiled “how does the world still rotate around my subjective experience given this thing writes better Tolkien fan fiction than I do”.
Performance on tasks. Everyone else shuffle over to the Philosophy department.
Otherwise brilliant and rational people just go all mystical when we start talking about meaningless words like “intelligence” or “consciousness”.
An animal or a human or a big matrix perform X well on Y task. That’s quantitative and objective.
All this “is it smart” bullshit is thinly-veiled “how does the world still rotate around my subjective experience given this thing writes better Tolkien fan fiction than I do”.
Performance on tasks. Everyone else shuffle over to the Philosophy department.