Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Like VSCode, it’s an example of exploiting our natural affinity towards convenience...

This makes no sense. Our GitHub lock-in is due to the audience. If a FOSS project leaves, they lose the GitHub audience. It's a social network.

VSCode is absolutely nothing like that. You seem to be condemning Microsoft for making a really good product.

Is JetBrains also evil for their suite of amazing, convenient products?




I had thought that JetBrains products requires a licence, unlike VSCode which is free in regards to monetary cost.

However - the main gripe this community has with VSCode is that it is only partially open source. Microsoft adds extra bits to the code that is not open - mainly the items around telemetry. You can get around this with VSCodium or VSCode-OSS, but those are arguably forks and not a MS product.


I still don't understand why that's an issue. VSCode is a proprietary product. There are tons of FOSS alternatives if it doesn't work for someone or the telemetry is a problem.

My criticism would only be that the telemetry is not obvious enough for a casual downloader. I don't use VSCode but I'm sure a lot of people do without knowing about it.


The main selling point of VSCode is their extension ecosystem. Most extensions are open source / created by the community. In essence, Microsoft channels FOSS work by third parties in order to create a pipeline for upselling their products and services.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: