Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

But I have written code which is hosted on GitHub which other people have uploaded and I have signed no agreement to let them do so. Does this mean all open source projects older than GitHub need to stop using it?



No idea at that point. If the code had a license that forbid reupload you could ask GitHub to remove it.

Otherwise that's the price of open source, you don't get to choose.


> If the code had a license that forbid reupload you could ask GitHub to remove it.

Licenses don't need to forbid re-upload generally to be incompatible with GitHub. Given that uploading to GitHub, according to someone quoted on page 1 of this discussion, grants GitHub the right to use that code to "improve their service" (whatever that means -- maybe Copilot?), not explicitly granting that right to them, or the right for someone else to grant it to them, is enough to make them not allow uploading to GitHub.

So that should be more like: "If the code had a license that didn't specifically allow Microsoft to use it to 'improve the GitHub service' you could order GitHub to remove it."


You do get to choose what license you release under and people need to respect that license - ML code laundering or not.


I'm aware, that doesn't contradict what I just said at all.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: