Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

There's a distinct cost to that lack of doom. In fact, "lack of doom" depends entirely on where you live in Japan. Most of the country is somewhere on the spectrum of "moving to Tokyo" for economic opportunity. Smaller cities just seem to be a waypoint on that journey.

Japanese work long hours and don't make very much money. The average salary is just under 54k USD. People continue to work well into old age and in many ways Japan's culture and history are becoming lost due to the rural/suburban exodus.




> moving to Tokyo" for economic opportunity.

This is happening on every country on earth and for good reason. Cities are more efficient. (Growth Ponzi Scheme)

> Japanese work long hours and don't make very much money.

That's culture and not an economic necessity. They also have a months holiday, maternity leave, and healthcare isn't 20% gdp. The French would say that Americans work a lot for little pay.

> People continue to work well into old age

Common in the west as well. Many countries have pushed back pension age since 2000.

> Japan's culture and history are becoming lost due to the rural/suburban exodus.

Cultures changes over time. Italian culture Italian culture did not include tomato sauces or pizza not to long ago. Hell, Italy wasn't a country! France didn't have a unified language until Napoleon


> This is happening on every country on earth and for good reason. Cities are more efficient. (Growth Ponzi Scheme)

This is missing the point. It's like saying "the entire US population wants to move to Washington DC because that's where the jobs are".


Interesting take. The majority of Japanese live outside of the Tokyo metropolitan area. Maybe someday that will be untrue, but I don't think it will happen for a long while. The other big cities in Japan are still strong and several of the smaller cities. Some small towns and villages have died or going that way, but plenty are doing OK.

But even in those places that are dying, people take great care to preserve and prolong Japanese culture and history. It is perhaps the country most interested in its own history and culture in all the world.


All of the also describes the US, except there are a few more cities (also more people). Even the numbers. The average salary in the USA is 56k.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: