Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Is the speed of light really the speed of causality? Would the effect of gravity (the lack of) affect Earth earlier than us perceiving the lack of light.



Nope. All physical effects are bounded by the speed of light. (As far as anyone knows, anyway.)

The only weird one is quantum entanglement, but even then information transfer doesn't travel faster than light and that's about all I know on that subject.


>The only weird one is quantum entanglement, but even then information transfer doesn't travel faster than light ...

For anyone wondering why that is, I found this explanation super interesting:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2020/01/02/no-w...


I also liked this explanation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7jctqKsUMA

In short, the only information you gain is about the outcome of the other side's measurement. They cannot introduce information into the particle, and thus can't transmit information. The only thing you learn is what you already knew: the other particle had a 50% chance of being in one state or another, with the added fact that it's now correlated to your particle with a 75% (depending on experiment) chance. This is information that didn't exist until that moment, so it couldn't have been sent out and reach you before you measure your particle, which would inform you with 75% certainty how your particle would act and break causality.


> All physical effects are bounded by the speed of light.

The universe expands faster than light. So this expansion is not a physical effect?


The universe expanding is a property of space itself. And "faster than light" is only because miniscule space expansion in any quantum of space adds up with distance, e.g. 1 picometer per kilometer per second, add enough trillions of kilometers and you get that faster than light expansion. There is no mass, particle or information moving THROUGH space faster than the speed of light, which is what the said limit concerns.


Why does gravity travel at the speed of light?


Well the other way to look at it is: gravity travels at maximum possible speed in this universe. Light in vacuum can also reach same maximum speed. I guess we would say the light travels with speed of gravity if we measured them in other order.


The speed of light is the speed of information propagation. Information about the sun disappearing would only reach earth at after c/1AU.


The change in gravitational force also propagates at the speed of light. It's weird.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: