Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Gold was a corrosion free metal that held it's shape with jewelers.

Even Silver corrodes. Gold never corrodes. It's excessively stable, malleable, and perfect for art pieces.

Since Gold is excessively stable, there are no worries about rashes or itchiness if you wear it all day.

In an age before modern plastics, that is basically miraculous.




Exactly. Gold still has these properties btw ;)

If people don't understand stone age economics and why gold was seen as valuable even before modern electronics, oh boy... How do they make sense of more modern concepts? We often discuss a lack of education, especially in terms of science and technology. The situation regarding economics education is so dire most aren't even aware there is an issue.


Does that explain why gold has been used to make coins and ingots, held in large reserves by governments, etc.? Surely the value of gold is and has for most of human history been much higher than what would be expected if it were merely a nice metal to make pretty jewelry with.


> Does that explain why gold has been used to make coins and ingots

Over say, Iron?

Yes. Because iron rusts. An iron-coin does not last forever. Copper, Silver, and Gold are easier to take care of, but even old copper/silver coins tarnish and corrode away with time.

Gold does not. A gold coin made 100 years ago would be as brilliant today as it was back then... with minimal maintenance.

There's a _REASON_ why gold was chosen, all across the world, from MesoAmerica, to Europe, to Asia, as a unit of currency.


This is a disingenuous argument because you pretend like gold has no downsides. The major, and very real downside of gold is that it's costly to store. The risk of confiscation is high unless you protect yourself with weapons. (And, in that case, doesn't that make weapons more valuable?)


I'm not saying that gold is magic, I'm just pointing out it has utility beyond it's value holding utility.


> The risk of confiscation is high

If that's your worry (and not that you shouldn't), consider that the risk of confiscation of your bank balance or stock accounts is far higher given that those are merely entries in a database held by a third party.


And historically, that was the case for all wealth stores, at least ones you could spend.


> The risk of confiscation is high

I got a buddy with a bunch of money in Celsius right now, that feels like its been confiscated.

Apparently, cryptocoins can also be "confiscated", and are unable to be sold during these times of duress.


>jewelry >art pieces

yeah, so exactly like I said, it was pretty much useless

>In an age before modern plastics, that is basically miraculous.

have you heard about glass?


Jewellery is a store of value with additional attached utility.

Have you ever worked with glass vs gold?

Dropped a piece of art(isanal good) made of glass and see it shatter and one made of gold and not much happening to it?

That's just two of dozens of reasons why your comparison makes no sense.


>Jewellery is a store of value with additional attached utility.

we're in the bi-hourly crypto hate thread. the threshold for being useful is set to "is it necessary for basic survival?". "a store of value with additional attached utility" doesn't make the cut, and must be banned to atone for our carbon sins

>Have you ever worked with glass vs gold?

the post above compares gold to plastics


> the post above compares gold to plastics

No one wears glass all day.

My Nylon strap for my watch is pleasant and cheap. But the very material itself didn't exist before the 1930s IIRC.

If we're talking about materials that existed even in 2000BCE, gold is one of those metals that you could wear all the time, and never get a rash, allergic reaction, or otherwise get itchy.

--------

Glass isn't flexible or malleable. Even if we use fiberglass today, its a carcinogen and very bad for the human body. Certainly not a material you want to be wearing all the time.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: