Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Hold on! See: https://github.com/dan-blank/hgrep-smallcore/issues/1 Using `fromJust` is deeply frowned upon, and indeed a few eyebrows were raised then showing my code to the examiners. This and a handful other warts unfortunate, but few and easy to work around.

This function and others are in the prelude, but one can use other preludes that don't have these escape hatches.

This does not undermine the huge benefits that people get from having IO checked by the typesystem. Just as having tyepcasting in a language does not undermine the benefits of types in that language.




IO isn't checked by the type system if errors aren't checked by the type system. Haskell could be better, Haskell should have been better.


Nah, the type system is perfectly fine in this case: "Given (Just someValue), return someValue". Exactly what happened here, the precondition just was not fulfilled and I left the case dealing the unfulfilled precondition undefined. If one cares about such things, one should simply use one of the numerous alternative Preludes out there (to make sure to actually never use fromMaybe, head and the 3 other functions that nobodoy uses form the standard Prelude) and turn the warnings for incomplete pattern matches on. At least, thats how you could deal with it in real life.

If it is not practical matters that are the concern here, there are more than enough languages that only allow total functions and offer other sweet stuff. Haskell's main purpose was to be a lazy-by-default-language, and that people can actually write practical stuff in it is a nice side-effect.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: