Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Yea but the pointscoring is literally all that matters, if you change the incentives you’ll see the behavior change with it.

If you take away the aspect of college as “a place to get a credential” you’ll see the cheating stop. Instead for those credentials just hold exams like the AP, ACT, SAT, RHCSE, or the 7 Actuarial exams. No college required. Whatever you do to pass them is fine.

Then make college totally ungraded except as a mechanism for student feedback. Have tracks for people that just want the credentials (just like the APs) that terminate at the exams. All other courses are just for people who are genuinely interested and confer no status or praise.

Now the incentives are aligned. Outside of the testing areas there is literally zero reason for anyone to cheat, and non-credential classes have to actually be interring, engaging, and useful to students for anyone to take them.




>If you take away the aspect of college as “a place to get a credential” you’ll see the cheating stop.

No, you won't. People will cheat because it is perceived to be easier than doing the work generally, even if they don't have the external incentive of the score meaning something.

People cheat at casual games of "Call of Duty;" not even ranked.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: