Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I am fairly sure Steve Jobs, Jeff Bezos & Elon Musk would have failed this test. Are you better off having them at your company or not?



Shockingly, there's plenty of competent CEOs who aren't assholes, but we don't idolize them because Americans love the idea of the genius asshole.


yeah , agreed -- but that doesn't really say anything about parents' point.

in fact it makes just as much sense totally flipped -- lots of highly effective people who have been successful in this world have had terrible interpersonal skills.

Presumably the point being made is that interpersonal skill doesn't predict success in business 1:1, and that deciding to throw a portion of applicants out due to perceived social issues is necessarily throwing out some thorny individuals with fantastic individual ability for the sake of the herd.

I can't say whether or not that's good or bad -- but as someone with terrible interpersonal skills myself I tend to hope that someone would alert me to my individual faux pas rather than silently ridding themselves of my presence all together.


Warren Buffett being a model example of a non-asshole CEO. Same with Kenneth Chenault at American Express, Indra Nooyi at Pepsi, and countless others.


Also Oprah Winfrey. Reports are that her public persona (warm, charismatic, friendly) is genuine.


I think all of those people are socially competent enough to mold the most efficient persona for any scenario.


Having worked for one of the people in that list, I can say that yes, I am definitely better off not having that person at my company.


Steve? I assume you are talking about Steve.

Yeah, that guy had problems.


I can't imagine any of them picking up and implementing boring jira tickets all day, so no they would probably be terrible hires for such a position.


I can't see any of them going for the IBM grad scheme though


This appears to be for an engineering position. I doubt any of those people would do well in such a position--they're loners, not team players.


I don't think any of those 3 could have been a good team player. They are entrepreneurs.

So yes I am pretty sure you don't want them at your company.


Similarly I wonder how many of those "top-of-the-foodchain" software devs and system architects were dropped during earlier job applications elsewhere, only because some brainfart caused them to fail the stupid code challenge.


Jobs was always an asshole, but early in their careers people seem to say that Musk and Bezos were reasonable team players.


Depends what you're optimising for - reliable, collaborative workers, or a visionary CEO.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: