Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

These are reflectarray radars, not AESA. No crazy specialist components are really required, just a lot of PIN diodes. I'm sure those can be made in Russia.



not sure where the proclivity to underestimate Russian military technology comes from. it certainly was a sterling hallmark of US leadership at the time of the cold war.

Russia has been making in-house AESA for a decade. they started with APAR radar in 1963, just a few years off from the US.

http://www.ausairpower.net/APA-Zhuk-AE-Analysis.html

they also sell the only radar capable of (on the open market) detecting hypersonics, the 59Н6-ТЕ mobile radar.


> not sure where the proclivity to underestimate Russian military technology comes from

They've been turned into bumbling idiots on Twitter and Reddit. It's a shame, but in my mind it is quite dangerous because sooner or later some president/general is going to make a very bad decision based on that meme. "How could their nukes possibly work?"


That is presupposing that said general/President gives two hoots about Twitters estimation of Russia's military capabilities...


God I hate it but events of recent years suggest that's not an implausible situation, sadly.


Guarantee that a SPY-1 can detect a hypersonic missile. It can target orbital velocity objects.


How useful is it to be able to detect a hypersonic missile?


It’s enough to launch a retaliation. So the expected value of launching a hypersonic missile is still very negative because you will get inundated with nukes yourself. It’s the old MAD doctrine, not perfect, but better than nothing.


I didn't realise it was possible to detect a hypersonic. What I read is that the missle creates a ball of plasma before it, which is opaque to radar. I thought this was the main strength of hypersonics, over raw speed.


Very useful. Hypersonics shorten the window for defensive engagement but don't completely eliminate it. For example in surface naval warfare anti missile defense is layers of counter systems / munitions. The innermost layers of this "onion" of protection are fast reaction systems that function essentially at line of sight (SeaRAM and similar missiles, CIWS). That an incoming hypersonic is trying to shorten the detection window is all the more reason that detecting one quickly after it comes above the horizon is valuable.


Maybe you get a chance to run outside before it hits?

But if you can get something lofted to get in its way before it hits you, it is unlikely to survive that.


At a mile a second I think the chances of that are somewhat limited unless you already happen to be in the flight path.


If it's coming toward you, just popping up between you and it is enough. It's not like it can steer around.


> It's not like it can steer around.

I thought that was one of the key abilities of hypersonic missile: that they can indeed steer around things?

That said, this is far far outside my wheelhouse, so I admit to ignorance.


> It's not like it can steer around.

The bad news is Hypersonic glide vehicles can steer around.


Not and still hit what is right behind what they have steered around.


Right now? It’s good for data collection




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: