Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That has a feel good populist sense to it, but do you have evidence that your idea would improve things? What exactly is your proposal?

Computers are better at processing information then people, eventually they will be able to determine, in microseconds, what the market effects of world events are and execute trades. I think the world will be better off for it, not worse.




Why would the world be better off with computers making trades?

I don't have a proposal, except that the financial industry needs to be reviewed. A good start would be to remove the products that are abstractions of the value of companies or markets rather than representative of real value. Eliminate futures and most forms of derivatives. Keep shares and managed/indexed funds. Keep everything physical (e.g. Gold, Oil, etc).

That would reduce a number of the swings in the market caused by relatively small real stock movement. Return the market to trading value, rather than trading the anticipation of what might happen

The stock market should be used for trading companies, not shifting money from owners of stocks to the financial industry by having people manipulate it.


Eliminate futures

This statement is almost identical to "Eliminate automobile insurance", for reasons you don't understand. General advice: Don't speak on that which your ignorance is total.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: