Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Who are all of these people who will be hurt by it?

There's nothing interesting (e.g. terrorism, bombs) you can do with nuclear waste, and it's not especially poisonous.

If you just loaded it up in barrels and dropped it at the bottom of the ocean, what's the worst that could happen?

Sure, some fish would die, but where are the millions of deaths?




> There's nothing interesting (e.g. terrorism, bombs) you can do with nuclear waste, and it's not especially poisonous.

LOL. Nuclear materials, including waste, are extremely dangerous in evil hands. It regularly kills people by accident or due to negligence. Chornobyl was an accident. Just imagine what a team of motivated people with evil intent can do with a nuclear station or nuclear waste. Last attempt to use nuclear waste in war was in 2015: Russia-backed terrorist planed to use radioactive waste (Kyshtym) to throw a dirty bomb at Kyiv.


This is really not true at all. One risk is actually the overreaction folks might have. Ie, a big focus of the "dirty bomb" type plots are really around trying to drive big reactions. Chornobyl was a worst case scenario. My guess is someoen could go to the area they have closed off and find plenty of plant / animal life thriving in the "nuclear wasteland".

Most waste is processed so its for example sealed into some kind of material prior to burial. So recovery of the radioactive portion, concentrating and refining it etc would be a pretty major undertaking.

You may also be confusing the long radiation stuff with high radiation stuff.


Nuclear materials yes, waste no. Chernobyl was an active reactor, for example.

There's an inverse relationship here with the half-life. The most dangerous waste is stuff that burns up in a few decades, the type that lasts for millions will emit very little radiation per unit time.


You clearly have no idea what we are talking about, but I will not write about the issue with nuclear waste on a public forum. I don't want to inspire somebody.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: