Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

CDN's should eat most of Cloudinary's market…

Cloudinary has two parts - a Digital Asset Manager for storing content - an service for optimising / resising images (and video) that then uses Cloudflare, Fastly etc as a CDN

Akamai, Cloudflare, Fastly all already have image optimisation services, so if you're using them already why use Cloudinary.

The DAM piece is more of an issue as most CMSs aren't great on the asset management front but looking at commerce etc platforms they're getting better




Cloudinary does a lot more than asset management, the depth of at-request-time functionality you can get just by URL params alone (like cropping with face detection...) is untouched by any of the cdn offerings of "let me resize/compress that for you".

The only thing that is shitty about the cloudinary model is the bandwidth costs. If someone could combine the functionality of cloudinary (it is genuinely unmatched in the space) with the cost of cloudflare... I'm in. They're even doing a great job on video editing (changing encoding format, bitrate, container, splicing in audio, cropping, thumbnail...) again using the same "just change the url and it's done" approach.

Saying CDNS will eat this by offering mediocre asset management is not apt.


Cloudinary is an end-to-end solution for managing images and videos, for developers. The CDN and optimization parts are tightly coupled with the digital asset management: e.g. if you change an image, the system knows to invalidate the relevance cached images, and is CDN-agnostic. So no, CDNs are not competition, but rather good partners to Cloudinary.

Regarding the DAM: CMS and Ecom systems are indeed getting better, but media assets you upload to them become siloed in the CMS. Cloudinary acts as a headless DAM that you can embed in any CMS and use as a single source of truth, relieving a lot of the pains of handling media files and their versions.

FD: I'm a Cloudinary employee


Yeh, I'm well aware of what Cloudinary does and I've used it with clients.

I've also used CDNs and CMSs to achieve the same thing including invalidating images in CDN caches when they change

Given the choice I'd always go for a solution that uses one of the good three CDNs combined with a CMS that can invalidated edge content




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: