Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The answer from the developer of Awesome Screenshot:

  ===
  Developer 1 hour
  @All, since many of you don't like this feature, we removed
  it in the version 3.2.1.

  ===
  Developer 39 minutes
  @All,
  Hi All, This is Joel, developer of awesome screenshot. I am so sorry to add 
  the amazon search result in google search result page without info 
  our users first. It's such a bad decision.

  This additional features was designed to scratch our own itch. Because when 
  I search some shopping items in google, I always want to check them 
  in amazon at the same time.

  In the spirit of transparency, we should disclose that this feature 
  does bring small amount of revenue to us, which enables us to continue 
  to improve this product. Since so many users don't like it, 
  *we already updated a new version(3.2.1) to remove this feature*.
I think they should make this feature optional and disabled by default.



Nobody would ever see it. Enabling new feature discovery in software is a very hard problem. Just throwing in features and hoping people will find them is not a good philosophy.

In this case, I would probably have shown it by default with text including "why am I seeing this?" and a "don't show this anymore" button.


I provided a customize button beside the amazon search result page for users to disable it. But it seems many users don't like it, so I removed this feature completely.


You are facing two problems:

1. The feature is orthogonal to the plugin. Alone, you probably could have survived this one.

2. The feature came to light for many through negative press. With number 1, that pretty much kills the feature in the current extension.

Rather than just killing the feature altogether, though, you could release it as a new extension. Add a couple other ecommerce sites and call it a shopping assistant.


Thanks for your suggestion. I will release it as a new extension if I have enough time.


I think they should make a separate extension that implements this feature. If it's really an itch that needs to be scratched, people will install it.

But I doubt it will be as popular.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: