Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The oppression is being barred from travel, work, and many aspects of public life.

I'm sorry, but you're not oppressed. You've decided not to take a free and effective vaccine, and society is going to make collective public health decisions whether you participate or not.




I’m pro-vax, anti-authoritarianism. I realize this is hard for a lot of people (like yourself?) but it really shouldn’t be.


> I’m pro-vax, anti-authoritarianism.

This is a bizarre (and uniquely contemporaneous and American) notion of "authoritarianism." We really are a country of new and strange ideas!


Not really. If you disagree, I dare you to burn your vaccination card and see how life is for you over the coming months.

There are many people like me who do not like seeing what is going on and are fully vaccinated. We have read enough history and have seen the hatred forming towards people divided on political and cultural lines, as the state pushes the envelope of acceptable oppression as it always does. Authoritarianism only happens when enough people can form a “reasonable” argument justifying it, usually out of fear or hatred of others, not rationally. Given the lack of acceptance of natural immunity, rationality seems not a full explanation.

Just because you think getting vaccinated is a good idea doesn’t mean you can ignore oppression around you towards those who are trying to defend their right to body autonomy. Besides, what if you are next?


> Not really. If you disagree, I dare you to burn your vaccination card and see how life is for you over the coming months.

New York state, in its infinite wisdom, has electronic vaccine records. There's even a blockchain involved, for some reason.

I shared my vaccine records with my elementary school, middle school, high school, and college before attending each. If I had burned those records, they would have made me get vaccinated again. But that doesn't make me "oppressed," it makes me a fool who burned my vaccine records.

> Besides, what if you are next?

Oblique comparisons to the Holocaust are as ridiculous and offensive as direct ones.


I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt and presume you’re deliberately trying to not understand here.


> they would have made me get vaccinated again

Doubt.


> Doubt.

I was required to get a DTaP vaccine in college (in another state, mind you) because I couldn't prove that I had gotten one as an adolescent. I had gotten one, but I'd lost the record.


Ahh I see so you were required in college, but not in high school and under.


No, you’ve misunderstood: I lost the records between high school. I have multiple friends who were required to get their MMR vaccines again in high school because they couldn’t find their records.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: