Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You don't get it. This is actually the free market in action. People love to talk about the virtues of the free market, until they actually get one.

In a normal labor market, companies can pay based on geographic concerns because employees aren't mobile. In the case of engineers, designers, etc., these people can work from anywhere, including San Francisco. So, they always have the opportunity to make SF wages by working in SF.

But, the thing is, none of this changes when these same people move to Bumfuck Nowhere. The same companies are still competing for the same employees, who are capable of earning the same wages they were before. And, like it or not, SF is the place where a software engineer can maximize their net income after expenses. So, guess what? Companies in Bumfuck are now competing with companies in SF.

Remote work doesn't enable a truly free labor market, but it does significantly free things up.

Regarding people not being paid what they are worth, I know that. It's also bullshit, but that's another comment. And, as I said in another comment, you know that, I know that, and Google knows that, but there are lots of people out there who either don't know that, or just refuse to acknowledge it to themselves. And, if you're Google, you really don't want to open those peoples' eyes, because it reduces the information asymmetry about the process that you exploit in order to get people to work for less than they're worth.




> In the case of engineers, designers, etc., these people can work from anywhere, including San Francisco.

They can also work in Bangladesh. And unless you are thinking of standardizing pay for software engineers globally in any reasonable timeframe, this argument does not hold up.

What is an engineer worth? I have offshored to skilled developers at rates 1/5th the US rate, and they can do the same work.

The actual answer according to the free market would be to take every engineer of equivalent skill, globally, and find the average. That is what a software engineer is worth according to the market all of us are in.

And that's not SF pay.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: