Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't understand the point behind "casting" something in a home environment, unless one keeps the client unsupervised. It could make sense in contexts where say one or more unsupervised signage displays are connected to small embedded boards that throw at the screens whatever feed is being streamed to them. That would be ok, but what about home environments?

Let me give an example. I keep all my media in a home NAS (Nas4Free plus RAID etc.) as simple files (mpeg4 etc.). My home TV is connected to a RPi running Kodi that accesses the file list through SMB/NFS shares, as every other computer in the house. If I want to watch a movie, I use Kodi to navigate the file list until I find the relevant file and play it. There are no downsides since it's a one click solution, and the pretty good CEC support by Kodi and the RPi makes it a breeze (one single remote for both the TV and Kodi) but this way the file is being transcoded by the player (the RPi) and not by the streming hardware, which would be an often less powerful platform like a NAS. This also means the streamed content travels as compressed packets through the network, in fact loading it a lot less than for example it would happen when streaming it after transcoding. As a result, I could have like 10 machines watching each one its own Full HD movie on a home wired network, which would be unthinkable if the poor NAS had to transcode all of them on the fly, not to mention the much heavier network load.

So the question is: what's the point in streaming in home environments rather than navigating file shares?




If I discover a new movie trailer on my phone, and I want to watch it on my bigger TV screen, it's much easier to immediately cast the video that I've already pulled up than to try to find the same video with my TV remote.


Proper security, phones on a different VLAN.

No Bluetooth nonsense with notification sounds.

Better sorting via software like Plex or something else, then casting that stream to something else.

Casting doesn't mean transcoding either.

Casting to a group of devices that stays in sync.

My Chromecast Audios will be online for a very long time.


If you have multiple smart TVs in your house, it’s simpler to have a single media server and connect to it via the smart TV software.


My example was with each Smart TV / PC / Media Box, etc. watching different programmes at the same time from the same NAS. By treating everything as a file it is being sent as compressed therefore not loading excessively the NAS or clogging the network with much higher bitrates.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: